|Description||A twist that resurrects players who have been eliminated previously in the season and gives them a chance to return.|
- Evil Valentine - Ejected from the game in "She's One Tough Bitch" refusing to follow the rules of her Mute.
- Lindsey - The official first person voted out in "She's One Tough Bitch". Lindsey won the Outcasts challenge, letting her return to the game. She recieved 3rd place.
- Cierra - Third voted out in "If He Thinks He's Getting My Vote To Save Him, Haha, He's Wrong!", as a victim of the International Justice League of Super Acquaintances.
- London - Blindsided by the IJLSA in "HEROES DO NOT DRINK THE BLOOD OF OTHER HEROES".
In Oaxaca the Outcasts twist takes place in "Knowing Things Is Mainstream, I Like Surprises", in place of the immunity challenge. Four players return for one more shot, not including Buckley, Sophie, or Carmonte who were also voted out prior to the twist.
All four players fought hard in the challenge, which was a reciting of the elimination order of the season thus far, but Lindsey ultimately won, putting her back in the game. Controversy arose when Evil Valentine claimed the challenge was unfair due to the fact that players who made it further were more likely to win. When the argument came that Lindsey was eliminated in the first episode but still won, Evil Valentine said she had won with the assistance of London.